No wonder Northern Ireland’s finance minister, Sammy Wilson, is getting antsy about NAMA’s role in what is a relatively small local economy; during the week the BBC reported that yet another Northern Ireland property company, County Down developer MAR Properties, has loans which are now managed by the agency. MAR Properties owns a range of residential and commercial property in Northern Ireland, Scotland and England which include shopping centres, pubs/restaurants, hotels and residential developments. Its most prominent development, as part of a consortium, was the 28-storey Obel mixed-use development on Donegall Quay inBelfast – at 85 metres,Ireland’s tallest building; MAR subsequently sold their interest in the development to the KARL Group. MAR is probably most associated with Noel Murphy (“M”), Adam Armstrong (“A”) and William Rush (“R”) who founded the group in 1997.
NAMA’s Northern Irelandloans are understood to total about €4bn, or 5% of NAMA’s overall portfolio of about €73bn. I can’t help but notice that Northern Irelanddevelopers make up a disproportionately high number of the NAMA-bound developers which are kept track of on here. It seems there is far better analysis of company accounts and press releases in the North, particularly by BBC Northern Ireland, than there is on this side of the border. At the start of last year the Irish Times published what it understood to be the NAMA Top-30 developers after what seemed like a straight-forward leak from the agency, despite the agency’s public stance that it won’t generally reveal the identities of its developers.
But beyond that report, there has been precious little research by the Irish (Republic) media to identify other NAMA developers; the Irish Examiner is probably the best for obtaining accounts and revealing NAMA involvement. But Irish News and Media (INM) the press group effectively controlled by the O’Reillys and Denis O’Brien seems, with some honorable exceptions, to sit back and re-report. The Irish Times is better but not considerably so – I didn’t see anywhere in our media (here and here for examples) last week the Financial Times being credited for breaking the news that Derek Quinlan’s Mayfair car park is close to being sold, the story was re-reported.
No wonder INM’s CEO Gavin O’Reilly can claim all INM titles (which include the Belfast Telegraph, the (Irish) Independent, the (Irish) Sunday Independent, Sunday World, Evening Herald and a number of provincial newspapers and part-controls the Irish Daily Star) are all profitable in their own right – if you don’t spend on investigative or research-based reporting and rely on re-reporting, it’s can’t be too difficult to contain costs so as to ensure titles are profitable.
Adam Armstrong has links to a couple of well known DUP politicians
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2010/jan/17/iris-robinson-parliamentary-questions-castlebawn
@ NWL Many of the developers are using unlimited companies which have to publish a much lower level of information. These are a complete curse, preventing details of huge swathes of the Irish economy becoming public in the normal way.
The grocery trade is worse with accounts for none of the main players available. All bar Lidl trade through these unlimited vehicles (Lidl Ireland trades as a branch of a German company.)
The original theory was that the members had unlimited liability, however the members i.e. shareholders now tend to be two limited companies in Panama or the Isle of Man.
Also the BBC has a follow up which suggests the NI Executive has a somewhat bullish view on medium term prospects for commercial property
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-15298330
@JP, thanks for that. But I can’t find anything in the BBC report which supports a view that the NIE has a bullish view on the prospects for commercial property. The BBC report seems to confine itself to the NI Department for Social Development having confidence in the preferred contractor for the mooted development in Bangor. Do you have any information on the development itself and why it falls to the DSD to manage the project? Is it DSD property? Also the BBC report suggests an application for planning permission in 2012 which will presumably mean a constructed product in 2013. One would hope the NI economy will be in reasonable condition by then.
Excellent Post,Its terrible that something that has the Potential To control the Property Sector for the next decade has received so little real and Proper reporting in this Jurisdiction
NYT Editorial which is very well read and influential has different opinion yesterday.
Britain’s Self-Inflicted Misery..
‘Austerity is a political ideology masquerading as an economic policy. It rests on a myth, impervious to facts, that portrays all government spending as wasteful and harmful, and unnecessary to the recovery. The real world is a lot more complicated. America has no need to repeat Mr. Cameron’s failed experiment.’
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/15/opinion/britains-self-inflicted-misery.html
Very interesting conversation on Dunphy this morning re above and O’Brien
What’s the difference between plagiarism and re-reporting?
It’s plagiarism when others do it:
http://www.independent.ie/national-news/columnist-goes-to-ground-after-serious-claims-of-plagiarism-2900141.html
Oct 4th 2011 – Exclusive:
https://namawinelake.wordpress.com/2011/10/04/exclusive-ireland%E2%80%99s-upward-only-rent-review-abolition-legislation-revealed/#comment-11037
Oct 9th 2011 – An Independent “Exclusive”:
http://www.independent.ie/national-news/new-laws-to-slash-rents-for-inviable-businesses-2900611.html
Coco Chanel once said “Imitation is the highest form of flattery.”
Banksy once “said”: