Greece on the verge of default provides Ireland with useful lessons

With there being strong question marks hanging over the draw-down of the fifth tranche of Greece’s EU/IMF bailout funding and a consequential default, there are some object lessons on offer that are relevant to our own circumstances. This entry examines them.

Greece has thus far received four tranches of bailout funding totalling €53bn, of the €110bn IMF/EU bailout which was agreed in May 2010. The fifth tranche totalling €12bn was due for draw-down in June 2011 but this is now in jeopardy as the creditors express doubts in Greece’s ability to comply with the bailout terms, and as infighting breaks out between the IMF and EU.

Last week, the troika of the IMF, EU and ECB abruptly departed from Greece and abandoned their review mission claiming there was no point in pursuing the mission when Greece was not engaging with the bailout terms. Although doubts in Greece’s ability to manage itself through the current crisis have hung heavily since last year and in recent weeks have intensified, it was still quite shocking to see the creditors walking away last week. Since last Thursday, the Greek government has redoubled its efforts to demonstrate its bona fides and yesterday approved quite a specific programme of privatisations and additional austerity measures. And the troika returned today and is now scheduled to remain until 6th June after which it will report on whether there is sufficient compliance by Greece with the bailout agreement to enable the release of the next €12bn. If Greece doesn’t get that €12bn, then it will be unable to roll-over some €13bn of debt maturing in June 2011 and there will be a messy default. And just to complicate matters, the IMF is demanding an assurance from the EU that the EU will provide funding to Greece to enable ALL debt maturing in 2011 to be rolled-over. The EU seems to be remaining tight-lipped in not providing any public response.

So Greece is in the wars. We have known that for some time, and we have watched from the sidelines. Greece’s bailout in May 2010 didn’t prevent a bailout here in November or in Portugal in April. Nor did the handling of the Greek crisis prevent the interest rate on our borrowings becoming unsustainable. We did observe Greece getting a 1-2% reduction in the interest rate on its bailout funding in March but have thus far been unable to replicate Greece’s success. So what lessons can we possibly learn at this juncture?

(1) Don’t wait until your coffers have run bare before deciding to try a managed default.Greece needs roll-over €13bn of debt next month and without that next tranche of €12bn from the IMF/EU, there is going to be a very messy default that could potentially see Greece exit the euro and renege on its sovereign debt.

(2) Don’t dilly-dally with implementing cuts and revenue raising measures, or state sell-offs. The IMF and EU will not be impressed with commitments given in the bailout agreement that are not then backed up with real action. This government is getting off to a very slow start and need to get a move-on with enacting new legislation in everything from bank resolution to personal bankruptcy.

(3) Permitting deficits is dangerous. Greece’s default is going to be really messy for its own people because Greece still has a stonking great deficit, projected to be 9.5% of GDP in 2011 (equating to over €20bn). And if Greece defaults and no-one will lend it money then it either needs to balance its budget immediately or exit the euro. Okay, the Morgan Kelly immediate balancing of the books might be unfeasible here, but remember the only difference between Morgan Kelly and the IMF’s official projections is six years and 15.5% compound growth in GDP. Yes the 15.5% growth will cushion the shock slightly but there’s still going to be a whole lot of cutting and taxing before we balance our budget, and bluster about “lethal injections” won’t change that central fact.

(4) Get your statistics and forecasting right. Greece has been plagued with revisions to statistics affecting its financial standing, that have been consistently negative. It is hard not to conclude that there has been more than incompetence at play. In Ireland’s case, the consensus now is that our growth projections in 2011 at Budget 2011 were too optimistic. And yet the Department of Finance in its April 2011 Stability Programme Update acknowledged that growth in 2011 might be just 0.8% but it is sticking to robust growth over the following four years and a 2.8% deficit:GDP in 2015. Unrealistic projections are not helpful.

(5) Face up to what is and what isn’t sustainable debt. The Greeks are buckling under debt of 150% of GDP. We’re not there yet and based on present projections will peak with debt at under 120% of GDP. Some say that our debt is sustainable, others that it isn’t. Regardless of who is right, we need to understand what is sustainable for our society, and if we are going to break that limit, then better to manage any default well in advance, rather than risk what seems now inevitable in Greece. Yes, we need to maintain as much confidence in our finances and creditworthiness as possible, but we also need a Plan B, even if it is kept under wraps until it is needed.

(6) Build bridges with Europe and elsewhere. Greece looks increasingly isolated in Europe, friendless at both the core and the periphery. Where is that charm offensive that Tanaiste Gilmore talked about in April? Seeking out friends inEurope at present might be too ambitious a challenge but we can certainly seek partners, communicate our position and seek better understanding of our partners’ positions. And as yesterday reminded us, we have friends elsewhere in the world. In theUS they mightn’t look kindly on bailing this small country out, but theUS has tremendous pull at the IMF which increasingly seems to appreciate our circumstances.

Greece might pull through these current difficulties and may get another few months of breathing space before default gets back up close and personal again. The interest rates demanded on its bonds suggest we are nearing a default. And we can breathe a sigh of relief that there but for the grace of God go we. But remember we have tended to follow Greece’s footsteps closely throughout this crisis.

Read Full Post »

Receiver appointed to TD Mick Wallace’s building company

News that Declan Taite of FGS was appointed as receiver by ACC Bank on 17th May, 2011 to Mick Wallace’s M & J Wallace Limited, the building firm founded in 1970 and which has been responsible for numerous developments in and around Dublin. The colourful plain-speaking 55-year old builder and developer topped the polls in the Wexford constituency in the February general election.

His financial woes have been known for some time. In March 2011, the Sunday Business Post reported that he owed €40m to the banks including ACC Bank. He said he didn’t expect to go to NAMA because his loans from AIB were below €20m and the incoming government wanted to keep those smaller loans in the banks themselves. Mick’s tale seems all too familiar, with his property assets dropping 75% from €80m in the boom to €20m today.

There is no suggestion from today’s news that Mick Wallace’s personal solvency is at issue at present, though it is a feature of our commercial lending practices that personal guarantees are frequently sought and given. Bankruptcy disqualifies a person from membership of the Dail, but there are around 10 bankruptcy cases a year here, so even if there are personal guarantees, an arrangement might be made with creditors.

UPDATE: 25th May, 2011. Iris Oifigiuil yesterday confirmed the appointment of the receiver to M. & J. Wallace Limited. Much of the media has now picked up this story and there are some new snippets to report. The Irish Times reports that the receivership applies to three specific properties only (1) his flagship property in the Italian Quarter on Dublin’s Ormond Quay (2) Behan Square apartment complex on Russell Street near Croke Park and (3) development land in Rathgar. The newspaper states that Mick has substantial personal guarantees but claims that bankruptcy is unlikely because “the TD has few assets and the process would incur costs for the bank” Mick has two other companies registered at 24, Ormond Quay – Wallace Calcio Limited which operates two wine bars and is continuing to trade as normal which will be re-assuring to the 50 people which the company employs (25 people per wine bar? who’d have thought). The fate of another company, Wallace Imago Limited has not been revealed. The Irish Independent reports that Mick in fact controls five wine bars which would make the 50 headcount look more reasonable. The Irish Examiner says that it was only yesterday that Mick conceded he had personal guarantees which could mean that the banks could bankrupt him but he is quoted as saying that such action would be “sheer badness”.

Read Full Post »